A quick recap, then the puzzle

If you have not read my post entitled “Understanding the term Increment”, here is the one detail you need from it. The increment is the minimum additional amount a player must add to the bet he must call to stay in the game, for his bet to count as a legal raise: Chris’s Mantra - “Call the bet you face and add the increment”. In that post, player C had bet 320 after player B’s 200 bet, and that bigger raise set a new raise increment value of 120 — the new bet of 320 minus 200 created a new raise increment value of 120.

If you do not understand what is meant by the term increment, you should read that post before moving on to this one. Without a clear understanding of how we establish the raise increment value, and what it actually is, it will be difficult for you to understand the 50% rule.

So now on to this puzzle. Player D faces that bet of 320 and puts in a bet of 400. This bet is bigger than the previous bet of 320 and it looks like it could be a raise? However, sometimes it is a raise, and sometimes it is only a call — this is not simply due to the total new bet value, but it is also because of how the new bet is made up.

As we get into the details of this 50% rule, let us first take a look at what part of a bet the 50% rule is associated with.

The 50% applies to the increment value and not the total bet value.

Assuming now that you understand how we establish the raise increment value, let us focus on this 50% rule which potentially forces the raise, and what that means exactly.

First and foremost, it is important that we understand that the 50% rule applies to the value of the increment only, and not to the total bet size. So at this moment, with an increment value of 120, 50% of this would be 60 in value. This would mean that technically, if a player were to place a bet of 380 or more as their new bet, that additional 50% of the increment should, by the conditions of the 50% rule, force this new bet to be completed to a full minimum raise of 440. But there is a very important condition that must be considered before all others.

First test condition: the Oversize Chip Rule

Imagine that player D places 4 x 100 chips into play, a total bet of 400. He appears to have added an additional value of 80 to the bet of 320 made by player C, which might appear to be a raise based on the 50% explanation above. In this case player D appears to have added more than 50% of the increment: 320 plus 60 is 380, and here player D has bet 400.

However, we have a very important consideration before assessing the value of the new bet made and the additional value within it. We need to refer to the Oversize Chip Rule to understand this. In brief, this is how that rule works — and it is the first and most important thing we should assess before even thinking if it is a raise or not.

When assessing a new bet made, we need to think about how much the bet would be if we were to remove one physical chip from that bet. This rule demands that this can only be the smallest chip available within that bet — so in this case, any one of the 100 chips from the four contained within the bet. After removal of that chip, what is left on the table must at least equal the size of the biggest bet in play, currently made by player C. In this case it does not: 400 subtract 100 leaves 300, which is less than 320. Therefore the Oversize Chip Rule dictates that this can only be a call, and not a raise despite the total bet value meeting the 50% rule outlined above. (If you do not yet understand the Oversize Chip Rule, see my post called “Oversize Chip, Single Chip Myth”.) This condition must be met before any consideration of the 50% rule can be applied.

The same 400 bet, made differently

What if player D made the same value bet using a different combination of chips?

Think about this scenario. Facing the same bet of 320, with the current raise increment being 120 and 50% of that being 60, player D this time makes a smaller bet than 400 by using 3 x 100 chips, 3 x 25 chips and 1 x 5 chips for a total bet value of 380. From this combination of chips if we were to remove one of them, and the rule requires it to be the smallest available (the 5 chip), this would leave a bet of 375 on the table, which is sufficient to call or equal the current bet of 320. That being the case we can now move to the second condition.

Second test condition: 50% of increment added

Once we have established that removal of the smallest chip does leave sufficient chips on the table that at least equals the bet of 320, we can now add the 5 value chip back to the bet and assess the value of the additional chips above and beyond the bet of 320. Here we now have a bet of 380 and because that number meets the 50% additional value beyond the 320 bet, here we have 60 extra added to the 320 for a total of 380, it is that 60 extra value (50% of the increment added) which forces this to be a raise. The player would be instructed to complete the raise by adding an additional 60 chips for a total bet of 440. This bet now meets the requirement to be a complete legal, minimum raise.

Additional chips do not guarantee a raise.

Just to be clear, even if we pass the first condition, where removal of the smallest chip does leave enough to call or equal the current bet, if the additional value, when assessing the second test condition, does not meet the 50% value added, then those additional chips would be returned to the player and the dealer would declare this a call of the bet.

(the word “call” here means to equal the current bet in play.)

(For more understanding of the poker terminology used at the table, see my glossary of terms (coming soon))

Next up: the Oversize Chip Rule in full — “Oversize Chip, Single Chip Myth”. And if you want to learn this properly, from the dealer’s side of the table, take a look at the courses at West Coast Dealing School, Las Vegas.

Chris Tidmarsh
West Coast Dealing School, Las Vegas